super mario galaxy Disscussion

I have many questions that can be discussed. So, I'll just start with one I saw other places.

What would you rate super mario galaxy and SMG2 on a scale of 0-100? I will give my opinion after someone else posts.

I haven't played either game much. However, they might look like a 45-70.

Well, I give SMG1 a 95/100.
It is my new favorite game.[used to be SSBB] It has good, original[as far as I know] levels and is fun and at about a medium difficulty, which for me is good.

I give SMG2 a 90/100.
It is a good game, but it repeats stuff [i.e. Ice+Fire Planet, Sand Planet]
Also, it is fun, but it is at about a very hard difficulty[in my opinion] and I think that is bad.

Well, I've probably played much better games. Nothing against Mario (in this context), but it's only Nintendo's luck that he's still a contender. Zelda: Ocarina of Time, Sonic Adventure, Pokemon Gold & Silver, Starcraft, and Tetris are all better than all the Mario games I've ever played put together.

Well, I've never played any of the games you just named, except Tetris, but I would assume they aren't for the wii. Why don't you compare it to wii games.

The best games that can be played on the Wii are Ocarina of Time, Majora's Mask, Starfox 64, Sonic Adventure, and Brawl.

Okay, let me rephrase that. Why don't you compare it to games that were made originally for the wii?

Brawl, Rockband 2, and DDR Hottest Party 2 are probably still better. Also, there's Sonic Colors and Sonic 4 coming out soon.

I was on a site that showed a bunch of lists of different sites that had top ten best games of all time, and here was one of them.

42. GameRankings.com (as of July 2010)

Rank Title Publisher Year
1 Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Nintendo 1998
2 Super Mario Galaxy Nintendo 2007
3 Super Mario Galaxy 2 Nintendo 2010
4 Grand Theft Auto IV Rockstar 2008
5 Soul Calibur Namco 1998
6 Uncharted 2: Among Theives Naughty Dog 2009
7 Metroid Prime Nintendo 2002
8 Tekken 3 Namco 1998
9 Resident Evil 4 Capcom 2005
10 Mass Effect 2 BioWare 2010


Just so you know, it shows the rank, name, publisher, and year made.

10. Fire Emblem: Blazing Sword (released as Fire Emblem outside of Japan.
9. Pokemon Red & Blue
8. Pokemon Yellow
7. Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
6. Metroid Zero Mission
5. Starcraft
4. Tetris
3. Sonic Adventure
2. Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
1. Pokemon Gold and Silver

Two Honorable Mentions are Jumping Flash and Sonic 3 & Knuckles.

What's that from?

Here's my personal list of best games:

1.Super Mario Galaxy (wii) 97/100
2.Super Smash Bros. Brawl (wii) 95/100
3.Super Smash Bros. Melee (Gamecube) 94/100
4.Super Smash Bros. (Nintendo 64) 93/100
5.Lego Star Wars:The Complete Saga (wii) 92/100
6.Drill Dozer (Game Boy Advance) 91/100
7.Super Mario Galaxy 2 (Wii) 90/100
8.Kirby Superstar Ultra (DS) 89/100
9.De Blob (Wii) 88/100
10.Pikmin remade for the wii (wii) 80/100

Any Honorable Mentions?

What are honorable mentions?

Games that would have made the top 10 list if not for the fact that other games were better.

New Super Mario Bros. (DS)
Pikmin 2 (Gamecube)

NSMB is decent, but not as good as Game Boy Mario Land.

Tant Pis! (Too bad in French)

Game Boy Mario Land was brilliant.

Tant Pis! (Too bad in French) (AGAIN)

GBML! GBML!

Tant Pis! (Too bad in French) (AGAIN)(AGAIN)

Anyway, back to SMGD

Which do you think is better, SMG1 or SMG2?

I don't know- I've only played a bit into 1.


GBML!

I enjoyed this game immensely. That is all.

well, I have no idea what to say now